[Recipe] Reuben Casserole

Casserole Wednesday’s here again!

This week’s casserole is a bit unusual. I was excited to try the recipe though, or at least my variation on it. It is a spin off of a reuben sandwich. I’ll admit that I was skeptical, even though I love reubens and smoked meat sandwiches, but I was not disappointed AT ALL. This tasted just like a smoked meat sandwich! Really!

Just as there are several variations on a reuben sandwich, I have made several variations to this casserole recipe, which is loosely based on a Company’s Coming recipe. Technically, this recipe isn’t “reuben” at all, since I’ve used Dunn’s Famous Smoked Meat in place of corned beef.

Regardless of how you decide to put this together, this week’s recipe is a hearty casserole baked with all of the goodness of a juicy meaty sandwich.

Prepare it in advance, and bake it when you’re ready to eat it.

The next time I make this, I’ll be using cubed par-boiled potatoes tossed in dijon in place of the rye bread, just to try something different. I’ll also use corned beef, since I love the stuff, and I’d like to compare the two versions.

[Recipe] Reuben (Smoked Meat) Casserole

Serves 8

8 – 10 slices rye bread (par-boiled potatoes would be delicious too)
2 Tbsp dijon mustard (or as much as needed)
16 oz smoked meat (we used Dunn’s Famous Smoked Meat), thinly sliced – corned beef can also be used here
1/2 cup onion, thinly sliced
2 cups saurkraut
2 cups swiss cheese, shredded
6 eggs
1 1/2 cups milk
1 Tbsp grainy mustard
1 tsp hot sauce (optional)
1 tsp worcestershire sauce
1/2 tsp pepper

No need to preheat the oven yet! This casserole takes some time to sit, at least 6 hours, before baking.

Spread dijon mustard on each slice of rye bread.

Cube the bread and scatter in the bottom of a greased 9 x 13 baking pan.

Scatter the sliced meat on top of the bread.

Spread the onions, then the saurkraut on top of the meat.

Sprinkle shredded swiss on top.

In a large bowl, whisk the eggs, milk, grainy mustard, hot sauce, worcestershire, and pepper.

Pour the egg mixture over the top of the casserole.

Cover the casserole with foil. Allow the casserole to sit at least 6 hours in the refrigerator before baking.

When ready to bake, preheat the oven to 350F.

Bake the casserole, still covered with foil, for 40 minutes.

Uncover the casserole, and bake another 40 minutes.

Serve. I whipped up some thousand island dressing to serve with it, since I love thousand island on my smoked meat sandwiches. It was just like the sandwich. So tasty.

5 responses to “[Recipe] Reuben Casserole

  1. This looks delicious!

  2. Could you post your recipe for the thousand island dressing? I did a search, but wasn’t able to find it… Apologies if I missed it!

    • You didn’t miss it. I actually whipped it up quickly based on a recipe I found online, but the recipe wasn’t my favourite, honestly. It was still quite good, but not quite right – it was 4 parts mayonnaise, to 2 parts ketchup, with 1 part dill or sweet relish or pickle mixed in. Add salt and pepper to taste. I found it just a bit too ketchup-y. I used chopped dill pickle, not sweet, since I like a bit more tang to thousand island.

      The next time I need to make thousand island, I’m going to try something more like this recipe (probably minus the sugar, and using dill relish):

  3. This looks delicious. Would like to know if you can assemble this ahead of time—like overnight (using milk, eggs, etc)? I’ve looked at several reuben casserole recipes and some use the egg/milk combination while others don’t.
    Any comments regarding length of time it can sit will be greatly appreciated!

    • Hi Kim – Quite honestly, I’ve not tried to assemble it ahead of time, so I can’t say for sure. I would venture to guess that it would be just fine though. Sorry I can’t be of more help! Come Fall, I’ll be making some casseroles like this and freezing them – if I make one ahead of time, I’ll let you know the results. Thanks for reading!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *